Apparently everyone in the world liked this film a lot better than I did. Though it was a sweet film with an interesting premise, I found it kind of boring and saw the ending coming from a mile away (not that that is necessarily a bad thing, but the acting and storyline just didn't offer up anything new or exciting for me.) I felt at times I was watching a Hallmark special.I think a much more interesting story would have been if someone put a bullet in Bianca's head and see how Lars would react to that. Would he implode upon himself? Would he be forced to face the reality of his world and meet the challenge? How would others respond? I also think it would have been much more interesting if Lars was sleeping with the doll. It would have put a much more darker and challenging spin on the entire story instead of the saccharine-coated, neutered fable that it was. Now don't think that all I like is disturbing, psychological movies. I enjoy a nice, feel-good movie as much as the next wuss, but the movie was just missing something for me.
One of the main reasons I watched the movie was because I was so impressed with Ryan Gosling's performance in Fracture. Here, I feel his talent is wasted as he is forced to play a repressed, delusional man that seems like he is on Prozac entire time. He does play it very well, and actually reminded me a lot of a guy I went to rehab with who eventually went crazy (or was a little off-balanced from the get go). He was my friend's roommate after rehab, and one day my friend returned from a trip to find that he had waxed his dog, had a washed a bunch of newspapers (which were hanging on clotheslines strung throughout the apartment) because they were dirty, and had a dried turd collection on the kitchen table. I half expected Gosling to go Slingblade on us at some point, but that never happened. Even though Gosling did play that character very well, it's kinda like stuttering, you don't want to sit through an entire movie where the main character stutters all the time.
There were good performances all around. I particularly liked Paul Schneider's performance as the brother. He had some really good, non-verbal reactions at times, but after awhile I got tired of his stammering--like a mid-western version of Hugh Grant. When I saw Patricia Clarkson as the doctor/psychologist for the first time, I thought, "Damn! She sure is a GILF!" Then I found out that she's only 48! That's only six years older than me!!
Director Craig Gillespie seems to have some talent at pulling at the heartstrings, perhaps from his 16 years of experience directing commercials (I'm guessing Hallmark cards and feminine hygiene products). Though he did direct Mr. Woodcock as well (which I haven't seen yet and probably won't, but understand is a little less sweet), I think he needs to get dark for awhile, really dark. Then maybe he can come back and make some good, sweet-but-not-so-sweet movies. I think it's like being a great abstract painter: You have to be a really good realistic painter first before you can truly start abstracting from reality.
Lars and the Real Girl (2007)
Starring: Ryan Gosling, Emily Mortimer, Paul Schneider, Bianca
Directed by: Craig Gillespie
(4 out of 7 skinks)









